Christian Is a Name. Love Is the Evidence.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
We Christians have quite a collection of labels.
Conservative. Progressive. Evangelical. Traditional. Bible-believing. Spirit-filled.
Sometimes those words help explain what we believe. Sometimes they help us find a community.
And sometimes we use them to decide who belongs—and who doesn’t.
But there is a question underneath all those labels that deserves our attention:
When someone encounters our Christianity, what do they experience?
Do they feel heard? Do they find compassion? Do they encounter someone willing to help carry a burden?
Or do they feel as though they have walked into a courtroom, and we have already appointed ourselves the judge?
Today, I want to consider two tendencies that can shape the way we practice our faith: legalism and empathy.
These are tendencies any of us can develop. Sometimes both show up in the same person, on the same afternoon.
Legalism begins to take hold when keeping the rules becomes the measure of someone’s worth. We become so occupied with whether people meet our expectations that we stop paying attention to their circumstances.
Empathy asks us to listen. To consider what another person may be carrying. To remember that the life we can see is only part of their story.
And empathy does not require us to abandon our convictions. It requires us to remember that we are dealing with a human being.
In Mark chapter 3, Jesus encounters a man with a withered hand in a synagogue. Some people are watching to see whether Jesus will heal him on the Sabbath, so they can accuse him.
Consider that scene.
There is a man who needs help. There is someone present who can help him.
And there are people watching for a violation.
Jesus asks whether it is lawful on the Sabbath to do good or to do harm, to save life or to kill. They remain silent.
The passage describes Jesus looking at them with anger and grieving over their hardness of heart. Then he heals the man.
That is a sobering picture: people can be intensely concerned with religious observance while becoming unresponsive to the suffering directly in front of them.
We should approach that story carefully. Jesus and those debating him were Jewish. This was a dispute within their religious community, and it gives Christians no grounds for dismissing Judaism as legalistic.
It does give us reason to examine our own hearts.
Because Christians can do precisely the same thing.
We can defend a church policy while ignoring the person it hurts. We can win an argument about morality while humiliating someone who came looking for help. We can become so concerned with appearing faithful that we forget to act faithfully toward our neighbor.
In Luke chapter 18, Jesus tells the story of two men praying: a Pharisee and a tax collector.
Luke introduces the parable as a message to people who trusted in their own righteousness and treated others with contempt.
That introduction matters.
The problem is self-righteousness joined to contempt.
One man’s prayer becomes a comparison: look at what I do, and look at what that other man is.
The other asks for mercy.
We can hear that story and immediately identify with the humble man. But there is a trap waiting for us.
The moment we say, “Thank God I’m better than those judgmental Christians,” we have begun repeating the very pattern Jesus challenged.
Even compassion can become a badge of superiority if we use it to look down on someone else.
So this message asks something of all of us.
Those who place great importance on obedience need to ask whether their obedience is producing patience, mercy, and love.
Those who place great importance on empathy need to ask whether their compassion extends to people whose beliefs frustrate them.
There is no exemption for the group we happen to favor.
Jesus takes sin seriously. He also takes suffering seriously. His encounters with people show us that truth and mercy can meet in the same conversation.
We can speak honestly without being cruel.
We can hold a conviction without pretending we know everything about another person’s life.
We can recognize that an action is harmful and still help the person responsible find a way forward.
Think about someone who has stopped attending church.
We could begin by deciding that they have become careless about their faith.
Or we could ask what happened.
Perhaps they are caring for a spouse. Perhaps depression has made getting dressed feel overwhelming. Perhaps someone in that church wounded them, and they have never felt safe enough to explain it.
Listening may reveal a need that our first judgment would have concealed.
That is where empathy becomes practical. It changes what we do next.
We make the call. We bring the meal. We offer the ride. We listen long enough for the difficult part of the story to emerge.
And when correction is necessary, we offer it with humility, remembering how often we have needed grace ourselves.
Jesus addresses that desire to be seen in another passage, too.
In Matthew chapter 6, verses 5 through 8, he says:
Matthew 6:5-8
5 “And when you pray, you are not to be like the hypocrites; for they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and on the street corners so that they [a]will be seen by people. Truly I say to you, they have their reward in full. 6 But as for you, when you pray, go into your inner room, close your door, and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees what is done in secret will reward you.
7 “And when you are praying, do not use thoughtless repetition as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard because of their many words. 8 So do not be like them; for your Father knows what you need before you ask Him.
Those words deserve consideration in an age when we can put a prayer before hundreds or thousands of people with the push of a button.
Sharing a prayer can bring comfort. It can invite people to support someone who is suffering. It can give words to someone who is struggling to find their own.
But Jesus asks us to examine the purpose behind what we do.
Are we reaching out to God, or looking for an audience? Are we offering encouragement, or hoping people will admire our faith?
We cannot know someone’s motives simply by reading their post. A public prayer is not automatically an act of hypocrisy. Jesus’ warning does, however, give each of us a reason to examine our own motives before we press “publish.”
And his words about thoughtless repetition remind us that prayer does not depend on impressive language or length. Our Father knows what we need before we ask.
There is something reassuring about that.
We do not have to perform for God. We can come to him honestly, even when our words are few and our hearts are tired.
In John chapter 13, Jesus tells his disciples that their love for one another will identify them as his followers.
That gives us something concrete to consider.
Whatever label we put beside our name, what evidence does our life provide?
Are people safer telling us the truth about their struggles?
Does our presence make it easier for someone to seek help?
Have we made room for mercy, or only for people who already meet our expectations?
We may never agree on every question of doctrine, worship, or church practice. But we can take responsibility for how we treat the person standing before us.
Before we classify them, we can listen.
Before we correct them, we can examine our own motives.
Before we turn their struggle into a lesson, we can help them carry it.
Christian is a name we claim.
Love is evidence we offer.
Let us pray.
God, help us recognize the times when pride disguises itself as faithfulness. Give us courage to live by our convictions, humility to examine them, and compassion for the people we encounter. Teach us to listen before judging and to offer mercy as people who need mercy ourselves. May our words and actions make your love more visible. Amen.